How Do Doctors Decide Between Surgery, Radiation, and Chemotherapy?

By: David Grew MD MPH

"Cancer treatment is often not one option or another, but a thoughtful combination of treatments."

∗ ∗ ∗

When someone is diagnosed with cancer, one of the first questions is often: Why is my doctor recommending surgery, radiation, chemotherapy, or some combination of these? The answer usually depends on several things, including the type of cancer, how advanced it is, and the overall goals of treatment. Many people receive a combination of treatments rather than just one.

The big picture: local treatment vs. whole-body treatment

A simple way to think about this is that surgery and radiation are often used to treat cancer in a specific area, while chemotherapy is a systemic treatment, meaning it travels through the body. Surgery removes cancer with an operation. Radiation therapy uses high doses of radiation to kill cancer cells in a targeted area. Chemotherapy uses drugs that can kill cancer cells, shrink tumors, or help stop cancer from spreading throughout the body.

Because these treatments do different jobs, doctors do not usually think of them as simple substitutes for one another. Instead, they choose the treatment, or combination of treatments, that best fits the patient’s situation. NCI explains that some people have only one treatment, but many have combinations such as surgery with chemotherapy and radiation therapy.

When surgery is often considered

Doctors often think about surgery when the cancer appears to be in one area and can be removed without significant post-surgery complications. In general, surgery is most often used for solid tumors that have not spread widely through the body. If the cancer can be removed safely, surgery may be used with the goal of curing the cancer, confirming the diagnosis, or reducing the amount of tumor present.

But surgery is not always the best first step. If the tumor is too large, too close to important structures, or has already spread, doctors may recommend another treatment first, or they may avoid surgery altogether. A patient’s overall health also matters, because some operations are bigger than others and recovery can be substantial. 

When radiation may be recommended

Radiation therapy is often used when doctors want to treat a specific area without removing it surgically, or when they want to lower the risk that cancer will come back in that area. Radiation is a local treatment that uses high doses of radiation to kill cancer cells and shrink tumors. It can be used alone or with other treatments.

Radiation may be chosen instead of surgery in some patients, or after surgery if there is concern about cancer cells left behind in the treated area.  The treatment plan depends on factors such as the cancer type, stage, treatment goals, and the patient’s overall health.

When chemotherapy may be recommended

Chemotherapy is more often considered when doctors are concerned about cancer cells beyond one single spot, or when they want treatment to work throughout the body. Chemotherapy may be used to kill cancer cells that have returned or spread, to make a tumor smaller before surgery or radiation, or to destroy cancer cells that may remain after surgery or radiation.

That means chemotherapy may be used:

• before surgery or radiation to shrink a tumor
• after surgery or radiation to reduce the risk of recurrence
• instead of local treatment in some advanced cancers
• together with radiation in certain situations

Why some patients get more than one treatment

Many cancer treatment plans use more than one approach because each treatment can help in a different way. For example, a patient may have surgery to remove a tumor, then chemotherapy or radiation afterward to lower the risk that cancer comes back. In other situations, chemotherapy may be given first to shrink the tumor before surgery or radiation. 

This is one reason two patients with the “same cancer” may still get different recommendations. Their tumor size, stage, location, test results, and overall health may not be the same. 

What factors help doctors choose?

Doctors usually weigh several questions when building a treatment plan:

• What type of cancer is it?
• What stage is it?
• Where is it located?
• Has it spread?
• What is the goal of treatment—cure, control, or symptom relief?
• How healthy is the patient overall?
• What side effects or tradeoffs matter most to the patient?

Stage is especially important. Staging describes how large the tumor is and whether it has spread, and that knowing the stage helps doctors plan treatment.

Patient preferences matter too

Treatment is not chosen based only on the tumor. Patient preferences matter too. The American Cancer Society notes that cancer care teams use information about the cancer and the patient’s health to guide recommendations, but conversations about options and goals are also an important part of decision-making. 

That is why it is reasonable for patients to ask:

• What is the goal of this treatment?
• Why are you recommending this over the other options?
• Is this meant to cure the cancer, lower the risk of recurrence, or help with symptoms?
• What side effects are most likely for me?
• What are the alternatives?

Doctors decide between surgery, radiation, and chemotherapy by matching the treatment to the type of cancer, the stage, the location, the treatment goal, and the patient’s overall health and preferences. In many cases, the best plan is not one treatment or another, but a thoughtful combination of treatments.

–

If you are unsure why one treatment is being recommended over another, ask your cancer team to walk you through the reasoning. Understanding the “why” behind the plan can make a difficult decision feel clearer and more manageable.

To learn more, browse our library of general cancer-related topics.

Hire PRIMR to create custom video content for your clinical trial or medical product today

‍

FAQs:

Is surgery always the best option if the cancer is found early?
No. Early-stage cancers are often treated with surgery, but not always. In some situations, radiation may be used instead, especially if surgery would be too risky or would cause harmful complications.  The right choice depends on the cancer type, location, and the patient’s health. Talk with your care team about why they are recommending one local treatment over another in your case.

Does chemotherapy mean my cancer has definitely spread?
No. Chemotherapy can be used for cancer that has spread, but it can also be used before or after surgery or radiation in cancers that have not spread far. For example, chemotherapy may shrink a tumor before local treatment or help destroy remaining cancer cells afterward. Ask your care team what role chemotherapy is playing in your plan.

Can radiation be used instead of surgery?
Yes, sometimes. Radiation can sometimes be used instead of surgery, depending on the cancer type, the tumor location, and the patient’s overall health. In other cases, radiation is used after surgery rather than instead of it. Your care team can explain whether radiation is being used as the main treatment or as an added treatment in your situation.

Do doctors ever start with chemotherapy before surgery?
Yes. NCI states that chemotherapy may be given before surgery or radiation to make a tumor smaller. This is often called neoadjuvant chemotherapy. Patients should ask whether starting with drug treatment could make later treatment easier or more effective in their case.

If two doctors recommend different plans, does that mean one of them is wrong?
No, not necessarily. More than one reasonable treatment approach may exist for the same cancer, especially when doctors are weighing different tradeoffs such as side effects, convenience, or the order of treatment. The American Cancer Society notes that recommendations are guided by the cancer and the patient’s health, but discussions with the care team remain important. If you are unsure, it is reasonable to ask more questions or get a second opinion.